Debunked: Matrix Within Matrix
The Wachowskis make no effort to hide the Matrix-Within-Matrix (MWM) question. It begins in the first movie, when Morpheus tells Neo that all of our senses can be reduced to nothing more than electrical impulses our brain receives. At that point, we are forced to ponder our own existence and whether it can also be reduced to the same thing. The question is continued in the Animatrix short film, Matriculated, when we even get a direct philosophical discussion about this very MWM idea between the scientist and the main female character. As we're set up to wonder about this theory all throughout the movies, we think we have arrived at the answer when we see Neo destroy sentinels with his mind. Little fragments of this theme are thrown around in countless other places, from Matrix comics to Matrix sequels.
But as we find out from the Oracle in the third movie, Neo's gifts extend "beyond this world" (meaning outside of virtual reality, in the real world), and this power is derived from his ability to connect to the Source (see Neo's Powers: Stop Sentinels). I think the Wachowskis simply wanted people to leave the movies wondering, "What if my life were being lived in a Matrix - how would I know?" A movie premise such as the Matrix begs us to ask this question of ourselves, but such begging doesn't mean that it necessarily has to be the truth behind the movie itself.
I find the MWM theory to be not only unconvincing but dissatisfying (i.e. if I were to be convinced, I'd be hugely disappointed), not only because it renders all of the movies so utterly meaningless as far as plot line is concerned, but also because like good conspiracy theories, they cannot be disproven. Much like the devout conspiracy theorist, the MWM theorist often presents this unfalsifiable quality as if it were proof of its truth, when in fact evidence pointing in the other direction is much more ample, logical and simple (i.e. following Occam's Razor).
Clue #1: Neo's Real World Powers Only Affect Machines
First, Neo is only able to bend rules that are a direct result of his interaction with machines in the real world. His blind sight allows him to only see machines, and his ability to destroy physical things in the real world applies only to sentinels and sentinel bombs. Never in the real world do we see Neo bend spoons, do his "Superman thing" or resurrect Trinity. If the real world were just another layer of virtual reality on top of the Matrix, Neo would likely be able to do a lot more than just affect and interact specifically with machines in super-human ways. Neo chooses only to bend rules that have to do with machines, but doesn't bother to discover any other bendable rule in his new reality, even when the life of his loved one is at stake.
Clue #2: Audience Deception and Asides are Beneath the Wachowskis
In order to believe the Matrix is inside of another Matrix, we have to believe the following asides and points of audience deception occur in the movies:
- The entire conversation between the Architect and the Oracle would have to be an aside conversation for the purpose of fooling the audience. If these machines were part of a multi-layered Matrix, they wouldn't feel the need to have conversations about "change is a dangerous game" with each other when nobody else is listening. Furthermore, the Oracle wouldn't care if those rejecting the Matrix would be freed or not, because apparently there is no such freedom.
- When Smith cuts his own hand in the real world, under the MWM theory we are forced to believe that he is doing it in order to fool the audience into thinking it is the real world when it's really not (rather than thinking he's cutting his hand out of his own sincere curiosity about his new fragile sack of meat he finds himself in).
- If you've watched the movie extras (or if you're observant enough to catch such subtleties), you know that whenever you see a scene inside the Matrix, everything is given a slightly green tint, giving us a feeling of being trapped in a computer world (because of the green we see on an old monochrome computer screen, such as Mr. Anderson's screen at his apartment). This was done very deliberately by the Wachowskis. If we are to believe the "Matrix inside a Matrix" theory, then we would have to assume that the Wachowskis, again, are playing deceptive games with the audience, using green tints to fool the audience into thinking the Matrix has only one level.
- The most important part of The Animatrix is "The Second Renaissance" (parts I and II). Together, they make up a single animated documentary of how the Matrix came to be. If it is a Matrix inside of a Matrix, that means the Wachowskis' primary purpose in making the animated documentary was to deceive the audience rather than to inform us.
The other option is to believe that machines such as the Oracle, Architect, Merovingian, Agents/Sentinels, etc. are also enslaved as programs running in various levels of the Matrix. In this case, nothing that happens in any of the movies makes any difference. Agent Smith is a tool, the Architect is a brilliant moron, the Oracle is an all-seeing sucker, and the salvation Neo provided was just a big stupid farce. Under this assumption, why even bother watching the movies?
Clue #3: Machines Allow Humans to Know Their Enemy
If the Matrix were within another Matrix, why would the machines let the humans know their true enemy in the first place? Why wouldn't the second Matrix level just be another pleasant reality void of scorched skies and sentinels? A much more effective strategy than letting humans think they're fighting machines is to let humans wonder what in the world they're fighting at all, if anything. Humans would even be forced to consider the possibility that God is responsible for creating a mysterious world that has various levels of reality that simply cannot be escaped and are not meant to be escaped. Just as we cannot fix something if we do not know it's broken, we also cannot fight an enemy we've never seen, heard, or felt.
| 
Debunked |
| 
Debunked: Seraph Former One |
|